How do stocks react to earnings?
Pensor explainer · Data last computed Wed 11 Nov 2026, 10:33 ET
An earnings reaction has two parts, the gap at the next open and what the session does after it, and both differ a lot from one report to the next and from one stock to another. In Pensor's figures for Apple (AAPL) and Eli Lilly (LLY), the last eight reports produced close-to-close moves from −7.4% to +3.2% for AAPL and from −14.1% to +10.3% for LLY.
Where the move happens
A company reports before the open or after the close, so the first trade after the news is the next open. The change from the previous close to that open is the opening gap; the change from the previous close to the reaction day's close is the close-to-close change. The gap is the market's first price for the news; the rest of the session shows whether traders kept, added to or gave back that first move.
Two stocks, eight reports each
AAPL closed higher on the reaction day after 2 of its last 8 reports, with a median close-to-close move of −1.3%. LLY closed higher after 6 of 8, with a median of +4.3%. The full tables, with each report's gap, change and source: AAPL earnings reactions and LLY earnings reactions.
The typical size differs as much as the direction. Measured without its sign, AAPL's median reaction was 2.2% and LLY's was 8.2% (code's median of the eight close-to-close changes in each table, signs dropped).
What to take from it
- Look at the stock's own history. Two large companies can have very different reaction sizes. A stock's last eight reactions say more about its usual range than a market-wide average does.
- Separate the gap from the session. The opening gap and the close often differ; see does the earnings-day gap hold into the close?
- Eight reports is a small sample. It describes what happened; it does not predict the next report.
Figures: Pensor's stored earnings-reaction records (method in the methodology). This page is research and education, not investment advice.